I gave it a positive review in 2015
But, you can count 3 of my family members among the recent negative reviews. Both of my brothers, and a nephew, were describing it as one of the best RPGs they ever played. Then they reached the Deep Caverns...
No matter how much advice I have given them, they absolutely refuse to even install the game again. They hate how it changed. They hated how much your experiences there were affected by things they didn't know would matter (access to vendors).
Unfortunately all three prefer to play RPGs just once. Most people like that are going to be left with a very bad impression upon reaching the end game.
Even I agree that it is a serious flaw with the game that has yet to be fixed.