So how exactly does this quest currently work (1.0.2.2 experimental branch), and is it bugged in some way? After talking to Luben and going to the area where Duff is, I can't approach him, instead his girls tell me to beat it. This is how I remember it working before 1.0.2.2, so your options then were either killing them or presumably sneaking and pickpocketing if skilled enough. Going by the patch log there should now be a way to peacefully speak with Duff, but I can't see how that's supposed to be done.